Home: Alternate History Books Themes Anthologies Dinosaurs Dragons Military Native American Parallel Worlds Slavery Space Steampunk Time Travel Vampirism World Conquest Eras Stone Age Bronze Age Roman Dark Ages Middle Ages American Revolution American Civil War Western British Empire World War I World War II Cold War / World War III Future Glossary Alien Space Bats Alternate History Alternate Timeline Anachronisms ASBs ATL Butterflies Counterfactual DBWI Double Blind What If ISoT Our Timeline OTL Plausibility PoD Point of Divergence Secret History Timeline TL Books Against the Day Against the Tide of Years Age of Tolerance Agent of Byzantium Almost America Alternate Americas Alternate Empires Alternate Generals Alternate Generals II Alternate Generals III Alternate Gettysburgs Alternate Heroes Alternate Kennedys Alternate Outlaws Alternate Presidents Alternate Skiffy Alternate Tyrants Alternate Warriors Alternate Wars American Empire: Blood and Iron American Empire: The Center Cannot Hold American Empire: The Victorious Opposition American Indian Victories Anno Dracula Anti-Ice Anvil of Necessity Apacheria Aztec Century Back in the USSA Battle of the Bulge The Best Alternate History Stories The Big One Black Powder War Bloody Red Baron A Book of Alternate Worlds Bring the Jubilee Britannia's Fist Budspy The Burning Mountain By Any Other Fame Camelot Revisited A Change of Regime Children of Apollo The Children's War Clash of Eagles Cold War Hot Collaborator Colonization: Aftershocks Colonization: Down to Earth Colonization: Second Contact The Company of the Dead The Confederate States of America Conquistador Counterclockwise Cracken at Critical The Crystal Empire A Dangerous Energy A Date Which Will Live in Infamy Days of Infamy Death is Lighter Than a Feather Departures Designated Targets Desperate Times The Difference Engine A Different Flesh Disaster at D-Day A Disturbance of Fate Dixie Victorious The Domination The Dominion's Dilemma Dragon America Drakas! Drakon El Sombra Empire of Fear Empire of Ivory End of the Beginning Farthing Fatherland Fiends of the Eastern Front Fiends of the Rising Sun Final Impact For Want of a Nail The Foresight War Fox at the Front Fox on the Rhine From The Heart Of The Storm Gettysburg Gettysburg: An Alternate History The Ghosts of Antietam Grant Comes East Grantville Gazette Grantville Gazette II Grantville Gazette III Grantville Gazette IV Gray Tide in the East The Great Game Great War: American Front Great War: Breakthroughs Great War: Walk in Hell Guns of the South The Hammer and the Cross Hannibal's Children Ha'penny His Majesty's Dragon History Revisited Hitler Options Hitler Triumphant Hitler Victorious Homeward Bound How Few Remain The Human Front Human Nature If Hitler Had Won If It Had Happened Otherwise If The South Had Won The Civil War In the Courts of the Crimson Kings In the Morning In the Presence of Mine Enemies Invasion Invasion! The Iron Dream Iron Maiden Island in the Sea of Time Judgment of Tears K Lee At Chattanooga Lest Darkness Fall Leviathan Rising The Lion is Humbled Lion's Blood The Lion's Way Luftwaffe Victorious MacArthur's War Making History The Man in the High Castle The Man With the Iron Heart Marching Through Georgia McGwire the Pitcher Midas Sheffield & Co. Ministry of Space Moon of Ice A More Perfect Union More What If? The Moscow Option Naked Presidents The Napoleon Options Never Call Retreat New Zealand As It Might Have Been A Nomad of the Time Streams On the Oceans of Eternity One Lamp Operation Lucifer The Other Teddy Roosevelts Pacific Empire Pavane Pearl Harbor The Peshawar Lancers Philip K. Dick is Dead, Alas The Plot Against America President Gore Prime Minister Portillo... The Probability Broach The Proteus Operation A Rebel In Time Rebel Nation Red Sun Resurrection Day Return to Eden Revisions Ring of Fire Ring of Fire II Rising Sun Victorious Roads Not Taken Ruled Britannia Russian Amerika The Separation Settling Accounts: Drive to the East Settling Accounts: The Grapple Settling Accounts: In at the Death Settling Accounts: Return Engagement Severed Wing The Shadow of the Storm The Sky People The Sound of His Horn Spirit of Thunder SS-GB Stars and Stripes Forever Stars and Stripes In Peril Stars and Stripes Triumphant The Stone Dogs Things Unborn Third Reich Victorious Throne of Jade Through the Night To Bring the Light The Tranquility Alternative A Transatlantic Tunnel, Hurrah! The Trinity Paradox Triumph Triumph of the Third Reich The Two Georges The Ultimate Solution Under the Yoke Unmaking the West Unnatural History Virtual History Voyage The Way It Wasn't Weapons of Choice West of Eden What If? What If? 2 What If? Australian History... What If The Babe What Ifs? Of American History What Might Have Been What Might Have Been: Vol 1 What Might Have Been: Vol 2 What Might Have Been: Vol 3 What Might Have Been: Vol 4 Winter in Eden A World of Difference Worlds of the Imperium Worldwar: In the Balance Worldwar: Striking the Balance Worldwar: Tilting the Balance Worldwar: Upsetting the Balance The Year the Cloud Fell The Years of Rice and Salt The Yiddish Policemen's Union Zulu Heart 1632 1633 1634: The Baltic War 1634: The Bavarian Crisis 1634: The Galileo Affair 1634: The Ram Rebellion 1635: Cannon Law 1635: The Dreeson Incident 1812: The Rivers War 1824: The Arkansas War 1862 1864 1901 1942: A Novel 1945 1945: A Novel '48 |
Marching Through GeorgiaSynopsis:
Themes: Eras: Prequels & Sequels: This book is one of a series of books that share a common alternate history background. There are links between each of the books in the main series, but each is a separate story.
Related Books:
Review of Marching Through Georgia: This book is the first of the Draka series, and in my opinion, arguably the best of the bunch. Such a lot has been written (mainly online) about the series, it's difficult to know where to start, but I'll have a go anyway. Basically the book starts with a map of the world as it is supposed to be in this timeline's 1942. What we see, is a Nazi Germany that has apparently conquered most of Europe (except for the UK), including the European part of Russia, a reminant Soviet regime beyond the Urals, a Japan that has conquered the Eastern half of China, the East Indies, and a large chunk of Australia, a USA that includes the whole of North and Central America, from the Arctic to Panama, South America divided between 4 large countries, and most startlingly, a brand new country, the "Domination of Draka", which includes all of Africa, the Middle East, Turkey, Central Asia, and the Western half of China. The novel itself is a war story, but with a lot more background filled in both in the plot, plus in fictional quotations (from books, letters, etc.) which precede each chapter. The idea is basically the Draka, are entering the war against Nazi Germany, and an American journalist (who may perhaps be based on William L. Shirer Perhaps one of the main reasons why these novels have attracted so much attention, is that Draka are frequently used as viewpoint characters. Obviously this is neither comfortable nor uncontroversial given the abhorrent nature of Draka society - some people have wrongly claimed that Stirling in some way sympathetic to these views (he has said very clearly that he's not). Another thing is that the Draka are very well equipped - with automatic rifles, tanks similar to an M1A1 Abrams, aircraft similar to A-10 Thunderbolt II, and as a result some readers say that they've found themselves almost feeling sorry for their enemies - who in this novel are Nazis. At the end of the novel are some notes on various aspects of Draka society, and a timeline that covers the period from the Draka's origins in the 18th century, to their conquest of the whole of Europe (except for the UK) and most of Asia, at the end of the analog of World War II (known as the "Eurasian War"). As I've hinted out throughout this review, what with the maps, the fake quotations, the notes on Draka society, and the timeline, the book is presented as if it's a serious alternate history. This is of course is another reason for controversy - as we have a war which starts off very much like our World War II (and in the timeline in the appendix, we also have World War I, Russo-Japanese War, American Civil War, etc.), complete with historical figures like Hitler, Goering, Daladier, De Gaulle, despite the fact that there is a massive militaristic slave-holding society on Europe's doorstep. If you believe in the butterfly effect, this is just incredible, but even if you don't, you'd expect some of the other powers to take some account of this in their diplomatic and military policies rather than just fighting among themselves until they are eventually over-run. The plausibility of Draka society has also been criticized: they are super-industrialized and super-militarized, despite being a slave-holding aristocracy. They grow incredibly fast - less than 20 years after establishing themselves in South Africa as a struggling British colony with a tiny population, they've not only conquered the French colonies in West Africa, but they've also conquered Ceylon, Egypt, Crete and Tunis. I could go on, but the gist of this criticism is that they grow too far, too fast, and in a way that is arguably inconsistent with the type of society that they have. You know what? I don't think it matters. What makes these novels worth reading, and enjoyable, or at least interesting for many people, is nothing to do with whether they are plausible or not. I think the Draka are simply Stirling's idea of worst and strongest possible baddies. You'll also note that in the Draka series, you'll also come across just about every favorite alternate history device from dirigibles to Project Orion, and from steam war-cars to parallel worlds - and I think that's part of the same pattern. My impression is that Stirling is trying to push the genre to its limits, and using Draka as viewpoint characters is simply another one of those games that Stirling plays with his readers. Your Comments Please leave a comment and tell us what you think:
Disclosure: The following products' details and descriptions provided by Amazon.com. Our company may receive a payment if you purchase products from them after following a link from this website.
|
|
Copyright (C) 2007-2023, Answers 2000 Limited CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE,COMES FROM AMAZON EU S.à r.l. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME. Disclosure: Our company's websites' content (including this website's content) includes advertisements for our own company's websites, products, and services, and for other organization's websites, products, and services. In the case of links to other organization's websites, our company may receive a payment, (1) if you purchase products or services, or (2) if you sign-up for third party offers, after following links from this website. Unless specifically otherwise stated, information about other organization's products and services, is based on information provided by that organization, the product/service vendor, and/or publicly available information - and should not be taken to mean that we have used the product/service in question. Additionally, our company's websites contain some adverts which we are paid to display, but whose content is not selected by us, such as Google AdSense ads. For more detailed information, please see Advertising/Endorsements Disclosures Our sites use cookies, some of which may already be set on your computer. Use of our site constitutes consent for this. For details, please see Privacy. Click privacy for information about our company's privacy, data collection and data retention policies, and your rights. Contact Us Privacy Terms of Use Advertising/Endorsements Disclosures In Association With Amazon.com Answers 2000 Limited is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. In Association With Amazon.co.uk Answers 2000 Limited is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.co.uk. As an Amazon Associate, our company earns from qualifying purchases. Amazon, the Amazon logo, Endless, and the Endless logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. All trademarks are property of their respective owners. All third party content and adverts are copyright of their respective owners. |